We are an independent insurance agency that specializes in Medicare, life, auto and homeowners insurance.

We are here to serve you. Contact us today for a FREE quote.

ESTABLISHED IN 2014 & Located in Muncie, IN

Home Insurance

Auto Insurance

Health Insurance

Life Insurance

In addition to Home, Auto, Health and Life Insurance

We Specialize in Medicare

At Safe Key Insurance we understand plan options to payments and all the steps in between, so you can make a more informed decision.

The Company We Keep

What our clients have to say…

Safe Key Insurance
Based on 16 reviews
powered by Google
Bonnie Davis
Bonnie Davis
13:36 07 Jan 23
I needed to find some new car and homeowners insurance. I called Jeremy. He was aware of my husband’s health issues, so... he came to the house. Took all of the information of the company that we were currently with. He answered all questions that I had and took time to listen to our needs. He went back to his office and found the best company to benefit us. I finally found an insurance agent that puts the clients needs at the top of his priority list. I guarantee you this is a company that cares!read more
Kyla Bartle
Kyla Bartle
22:26 30 Jun 21
Finding an insurance agent you can trust to take care of your needs while your are dealing with a hectic schedule is... hard to find. Being a business owner, the annual renewal has a way of sneaking up on you! The Amos team is always on it! Contacting me at renewal, having already did their homework to make sure my family and business are getting the best rates and coverage. Huge weight off my shoulders not having to worry with this. Thanks to Safe key for making our lives a little easier. :)))read more
Crissy Matheny
Crissy Matheny
22:49 02 Mar 21
Thank you for the great customer service! If you are looking for great service and rates for your auto and home... insurance please check Jeremy out. He has always been responsive when I had questions about adding a kid to the auto policy’s or adding a new vehicle. A+ businessread more
Rosie Mccormack
Rosie Mccormack
03:17 02 Mar 21
Thank you Safe Key Insurance for all your help.Thank you for always returning calls and emails promptly!Couldn't ask... for better service!!They are very knowledgeable and professional and I am glad I found them! Very Highly Recommended!!!read more
Stacy Mills
Stacy Mills
17:48 01 Mar 21
Mr. Amos is very knowledgeable in his field, trustworthy, and very efficient. After I lost my job, he went above and... beyond to help me find not only the best short term plan, but also next steps for long term planning. He offered info to check other company plans so I was well informed. I couldn’t have asked for better help, for my pocket as well as my security.read more
Robert Shaw
Robert Shaw
22:27 12 Feb 21
I asked for a quote on insurance for home owners on my house and on my son's house, and for auto insurance priced on... the VEHICLE, Mr Amos would not do as I requested. I tired to negotiate discounts and he would not.I actually drove to his location from New Castle to Muncie and his office address at 3000 S Madison was empty, and I got there as the mailman was leaving and the mailman said the office is always empty, Mr Amos said it was empty because he had a full time job working some where else so he would not lose his Health insurance, he seemed more interested in his heath insurance than he did in serving his customers.Then he gave me the prices which were outrageous and claimed that my son who moved to Indiana from out of State did not have an Indiana License yet, which is true, but that does not disqualify my son from getting insurance and I have in writing to Mr Amos I wanted to insure the vehicles, Mr Amos knew so little about insurance, and what I wanted I told him the Indiana Dept of Insurance should know about this situation, then he says I slandered him. Really the guy licensed by the Indiana Dept of Insurance thinks it's slander to report his conduct?Go there at your own risk.2/12/21 Thanks to you for your reply, but I have 7 pages of information I gave you, all of which are facts including going great lengths to explain things. You then threatened me with a lawsuit for going on a consumer site, and yes I do have that in writing from you.Then you are under the impression that some how it is slander to report this kind of nonsense to the Dept of Insurance.There thankfully is a First Amendment which allows people on a Google site to air their opinion of the business, and Sir, my opinion is not very high of your business.That's my Constitutional right to say in this free country.So lets get facts straight, I have 7 pagers of information I provided you with.read more
Krista Swoboda
Krista Swoboda
21:59 11 Feb 21
I met with Mr. Amos for quotes on my car, home & rental property, he was able to decrease my rates by hundreds of... dollars annually and has kept in touch with me multiple times to check in. I also refinanced and there was an inside between the mortgage company and insurance company with my escrow and Mr. Amos went above and beyond to contact me and get the situation straightened out quickly to keep my insurance from lapsing or having further issues. I highly recommend anyone looking for insurance see him, he will work hard to decrease your annual rates and provide you with great coverage.read more
More reviews

Are you an existing client and have experienced great customer service from us? Let the world know by giving us a 5-star review on Google.